Our world is collapsing. Why don’t we face reality?
Do you want to read a challenging book about things that are ineluctably going to cause you, your children, your grandchildren unbelievable pain - that may even threaten the survival of all of us - in the coming decade? Think collapse of the Roman Empire and multiply it up to global level - famine, energy shortage, collapse of government, barbarian attacks, and then some.
No? OK, I don’t blame you. But nonetheless I strongly recommend you read Thomas Homer Dixon’s The Upside of Down: Catastrophe, Creativity, and the Renewal of Civilization.
Homer Dixon, Director of the Trudeau Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies in Canada, argues that the present global order is under unprecedented stress and that it could suddenly collapse catastrophically in the near future.
The thesis presented in the book is not the rant of a global-catastrophist nutcase, but a well researched and carefully argued exposition of certain realities facing the human race, realities that most of us would prefer to deny right now.
“When, next, will be see people walking out of our cities - in the darkness of a mid-afternoon?” asks Homer Dixon (he’s thinking of 9/11 and of the 14 August 2003 power failure across eastern North America from New York to Detroit and Toronto).
Maybe not long from now, because the possibility of abrupt breakdown in our vital social and technological systems is rising, and perhaps rising fast. Breakdown is often like an earthquake: it’s caused by the slow accumulation of deep and largely unseen pressures beneath the surface of our day-to-day affairs. At some point these pressures release their accumulated energy with catastrophic effect, creating shock waves that pulverize our habitual and often rigid ways of doing things.
Tectonic stresses
Homer Dixon believes that there are five tectonic stresses that are accumulating underneath the surface of our societies:
- population stress arising from differences in the population growth rates between rich and poor societies, and from the growth of megacities in poor countries;
- energy stress - above all from the increasing scarcity of conventional oil;
- environmental stress from worsening damage to our land, water, forests, and fisheries;
- climate stress from changes in the makeup of our atmosphere;
- and, finally, economic stress resulting from instabilities in the global economic system and ever-widening income gaps between rich and poor people.
Multipliers
Dixon also draws our attention to two multipliers that will give these stresses extra force:
- the rising speed and global connectivity of our activities, technologies and societies;
- the escalating power of small groups to destroy things and people.
Destructive catastrophe? Or creative catagenesis?
If all these stresses and multipliers peak together, we may have what Dixon calls synchronous failure, a destructive collapse of all natural, social, economic and political systems around the globe. Recovery from such a collapse would be slow, perhaps impossible.
Some kinds of complex systems, on the other hand,
adapt to their changing environment by going through a four-stage cycle of growth, breakdown, reorganization, and renewal.
If the predicted collapse of global order is constrained in some way, catagenesis (Homer Dixon’s term for the birth of something new and unexpected and potentially good from a disaster) can occur. That’s not to say that it will be easy. Far from it. But humankind and the planet may not be utterly doomed.
Rolling up the old world order, unrolling the new
Baha’is will recognize immediately the truth of what Thomas Homer Dixon is saying. Baha’u'llah warns that an “unforeseen calamity” is following humankind. Some of us have spent too many years speculating what such a calamity might be. Baha’u'llah also says that “the old world” order is being “rolled up” (like an old carpet) and a new order is being unrolled in its place. Well, I don’t think the possible collapse of all the world’s major systems has been foreseen - in fact, many would still deny that any such thing is happening. But it certainly would ensure that all the accumulated crud and rigidities of our economic, social, political and other systems are cleared away and that space is made for something new.
Why don’t we face the stark reality? We’re addicted to our oil-based, consumerist life style. Like all addicts, we don’t want to change. So we either deny that there’s any crisis, or we deny that the crisis will affect us. And then we wonder what we can do about it. It all seems too much. No individual or family, we think, can actually make any difference.
In fact, we can, each and every one of us, do things that will make catagenesis more likely. Thomas Homer Dixon’s thesis provides us with a compelling reason to study the teachings of Baha’u'llah and the life of the Baha’i community, which is striving to build the foundations of a new global civilization, based on a deep understanding of the oneness that underlies human diversity and on social, economic and environmental justice. Actually, it provides a compelling reason to do more than just study the teachings of Baha’u'llah, but to step onto the path of service with the Baha’is and to join this global community in its work.
Technorati Tags: Baha’i, Bahai, global catastrophe, Thomas Homer Dixon, Upside of Down, global order, catagenesis
Start Slide Show with PicLens LiteRelated posts:













7 comments
Thanks (I think!) for the review of this book, looks interesting, I must put in a library request for it.
I found the concept of the five stresses particularly pertinent - the interlinking reflects in a dark sort of way our own connectedness as human beings.
Actually, what I found gave a glimmer of hope in your review was the second multiplier. If small groups have an escalating power for destructiveness, then equally small groups have greater power than ever to make a positive difference. I hope so.
Tess, you’ve made an excellent point about the power of small groups to make a positive difference (as well as the undoubted power they have to be destructive). Many years ago, when I was studying social psychology for a degree, I learned about research that demonstrated clearly that minorities with clear and consistent messages can be more effective in changing the opinions of the majority than the majority itself.
It would seem, therefore, that people of faith and good will, even though they may be in a minority, could do a great deal to counteract or mitigate the effects of whatever collapse may happen - and may help avert some of the more disastrous influences and actions that could make life a lot worse.
The message is, act now! Don’t wait!
[...] My photos on Flickr ← Our world is collapsing. Why don’t we face reality? [...]
[...] Our world is collapsing. Why don’t we face reality? [...]
[...] And talking about growth (stay with me, you’ll see the link in a moment), I’ve now finished Thomas Homer-Dixon’s The Upside of Down (as reviewed in this previous post). [...]
Everything that you have said here and the theories surrounding what we are doing to our World and our future and the future of generations to come are correct. However it is easy to speculate about these catastrophies that lay ahead of us but changing anything is another problem. Even the environmentalists out there more than likely go home, put their heating on because its cold and then turn the kettle on to make themselves a cup of tea and in doing so use 2 precious rescources that we have as a society come to take for granted and use as second nature.
How do approach a global problem like the environment when we have countries intent on destroying each other let alone the plans they have for other countries i.e. people who go out into crowded areas with the intention of blowing themselves up and killing as many innocent people as possible to ‘prove a relegious point.’
The only way I see people saving the world is when that same world and its subsequent Governments or ruling powers become united in the common goal to preserve the life and all life around them that we have.
But I may be wrong.
Simon, thank you for your very perceptive comments. There’s no doubt that united intention and action between the peoples of the world and the governments of the world are essential. The underlying question here is: how do we ensure that people have the intention and motivation to forego their own wants in order to save the world.
The Baha’i view is that spiritual and moral transformation, based on belief in God and a true understanding of human oneness will be the basis of the resolution of all the world’s problems. It may take some time!
Leave a Comment